I stopped by here a couple of Tuesdays ago with my fiance and another dining companion for dinner. We arrived shortly after 7 PM to find the place packed. The inside of Cenci's was quite dim with a bar straight ahead, a dining room to the left and a case filled with a ton of craft beer in it on the right. We headed towards the dining area to see only a single table left which we quickly took. Earlier in the day we had looked at their website to find out what the specials were and they happened to be $3.50 Craft drafts & $5.99 14" cheese pizzas. Whenever our server came over asked us what we would like to drink I asked what they had on draft. She did not know off the top of her head and had to go to another table to find her handwritten list. I ended up ordering a Terrapin I believe and by this time the rest of the table had decided that we would split 2 14" pizzas between us. Our food arrived to us in a reasonable amount of time and we dug into the pizza. There was nothing special about the pizza and it sort of reminded me of a frozen pizza. Boring crust that wasn't too crispy and some bland cheese and sauce that left all of us feeling unsatisfied. As a matter of a fact if I was writing the review only on the food itself, I would have given it two stars. What saved it was that our server was nice and polite and I liked the atmosphere of the place. My fiance and I also noticed that they were starting some trivia as we were leaving which we may be interested in for the future.
The bottom line for me is that I might be back to Cencis in the future but certainly not for the food. Their pizza was definitely lacking in something and all 3 of left the place unsatisfied.