I've been to Arcadia Tavern on many occasions for lunch and once for dinner and have yet to have a bad experience. My dinner visit was on a Friday night, so the place was packed and it took a while to get our food, but having been in the food and beverage business in a past life, I know how that goes.
I've tried 5 or 6 different menu items and they have all been tasty, cooked properly and presented attractively. The staff has always been attentive and friendly, and if I'm being honest, there's also some really attractive women working here! :)
The only thing that kinda sucks is the parking. There aren't many spaces and a good percentage of the spots are always reserved for the valet. Having said that, valet has always been free, except for the tip. If there's no parking, a few bucks to valet your car 12 feet from the front door ain't so bad.
Recommended!