We were surprised at reading some negative reviews and found out on our own that Gaetano's was very good and nothing like some reviews stated. Service was great and attentive but not overbearing. We started with ice teas and appetizers of Brietta and figs stuffed with goat cheese.. Only 3 figs so we had to split the last one (otherwise a fight) delicious. Mr. had the spaghetti and meatballs, normally he would have never ordered spaghetti but the meatballs made up for it.. large and absolutely delicious. I had mushroom ravioli, light and creamy and not overpowering. The dining room was busy for 530p on a Wednesday night but service was still there. I presented the groupon and when they brought the bill explained 18% tip was included. Nothing was hidden. So after the groupon and the tip we still owed another 42.00 which was worth it. The hostess did come over to bring change back (which we declined) and also said another groupon was out as of today 9-12.. Went home and bought another groupon. A real gem found in a strip mall.