I've been to Napoletana twice now which clearly means its worth visiting more than once.
My first visit was a Saturday afternoon and we waited no time getting seated- however, the three of us had to share a table on both sides with two different parties. I'm never a big fan of this.
The hostess was sweet and so was the guy who brought us out out water but when the salt-and-pepper haired guy came out I asked him what size the pizzas were (all one size) he looked at me as if I was stupid until he eventually pointed outside. I asked him again (at this point annoyed) and he again pointed outside. Given that I didn't see any pizza outside I asked what he was pointing at and he finally huffed and said the pizzas were the size of the empty plate I was supposed to be looking. All that when he could of just said 10 inches... All the pizzas are about 10 inches people.
My partner and I ordered the classic mozzarella and pepperoni and a fettuccini alfredo to share... The pizza was incredibly flavourful. The crust was crispy until the last bite and the mozzarella and sauce really went far beyond a regular pizza shop. The fettuccini was perfectly al dente and the sauce was sheer comfort.
Overall we were really happy with the food. about $40 for the both of us and very regrettably cash only so we had to withdraw from the ATM there.
I came back today during lunch (Sunday) and put our names on the list to be seated. We were five people this time and the host quoted us 10 minutes. We waited a couple minutes short of 40 minutes but at least got our own table this time. The staff was super friendly and patient with us. I passed on the pasta and ordered myself the "Rustica" pizza and waited anxiously. The crust was, again, unbeatable but the pancetta was insanely salty which made it uneatable. I picked it all off and still couldn't eat the parts of the pizza that had had the pancetta. I was all in all disappointed and still forced to withdraw money from their cash cow ATM.
I haven't given up on this place and I'm sure ill be back. Their dessert menu looks really tempting (Nutella cheesecake?). This place has open 50+ years so I know they're doing something right and that my review isn't gonna make them or break them so I'm gonna give them their fair shot!