Went there for the first time today (Saturday 10:00am) and was very impressed...best breakfast food I've had in Madison yet! I got one of their scramblers and a cup of coffee.
Pros:
Great food. Good value. BIG portions. Really friendly waitress. Once I got a seat, the wait wasn't very long to get my food.
Cons:
RIDICULOUSLY busy. No form of order...seat yourself. Cash only.
Great place and I'll definitely go back!
Edit: I forgot to mention to try their coffee cake! I got a piece of their apple cinnamon coffee cake served to go and it is the best $2 I've spent in a long time!!!