We went to this place because of its high rating on Yelp, and it deserves it.
We had too many items to list and they were all good. The fatty tuna sushi (toro) is to die for. The rice is cooked and prepared perfectly. It's a very pleasant surprise to find such a high quality sushi place in a small city like Madison.
Only two minor issues:
1) Soft drinks are from cans, so no free refills.
2) The cooked and fried rolls are not great, but I knew they wouldn't be (cooked rolls never are). I ordered them because the people I was with are what I call "white boy sushi" eaters and are not entirely down with raw fish yet. They were more comfortable after this experience.
Highly recommend.