This place is phenomenal, especially for being a little hole-in-the-wall spot. I've ventured out to Peppers a few times now, and all the important things are consistently great.
Service- friendly, down-to-earth and attentive. It's not just one employee, but all employees give you that warm and fuzzy feeling.
Food- Lasagna, ravioli, chicken parm... whatever you get it's going to be good. They have a great sauce and the quality of food is outstanding overall. Everything is seasoned perfectly. If you're lucky enough to be there on a day in the fall when they have their grape pie, do yourself a favor and get a piece to eat there and another one to take home. It's that good.
Price- A little higher than other restaurants, but for the quality and taste of what you're getting it's worth it.
Decor - not the most modern, but it's not so tacky that it detracts from the overall experience. It's a cozy little spot.
Lakewood is lucky to have this place!