I was excited to try this place out after seeing all the photos and hearing about all the hype. Many years ago my dad had brought home a compost cookie from NY after a business trip and I remember it tasting sooo good. I was excited to be able to try it again. My husband and I shared a cereal milk soft serve with cornflakes topping and a compost cookie.
Maybe it's the hype but I don't really understand how the cereal milk is so popular. The cereal milk flavor is pretty subtle and the cornflakes completely overpower the taste. I personally thought the cornflakes were much too salty and I didn't really care too much for it. Also, it's quite expensive too--an extra $1 just for some cornflakes!!
The compost cookie was pretty good but not as good as my memory makes me believe. It didn't taste that fresh and was also a bit too sweet. I like it but I'll probably pass in the future...$3 is a bit too much for a cookie that didn't blow me away.
Overall, this place is definitely hyped up. Prices are high and it's not really worth it. If I ever come back again I'll probably try the Crack Pie that everyone is talking about.