I really want someone to make a documentary about Mystic Muffin. This place is a true Toronto landmark. If you've never been there (which is highly likely because the exterior appears super sketchy - but I assure you it's all part of the charm!) then you NEED to check it out.
The owner Elias is HILARIOUS. He is the reason why Mystic Muffin is not only a place to grab food, but an experience. Elias is always behind the counter taking orders and making food, so you're guaranteed to interact with him when you're there. He will most likely tell you some amazing jokes and try really hard to sell you a famous banana loaf or apple cake (both of which are DELICIOUS.) But seriously, he's a really good salesman - it's hard to say no because you'll just love him so much.
Once Elias told me he was getting ready to celebrate Mystic Muffin's 20th anniversary. I asked him what he was doing to celebrate and he responded with "We're throwing a huge party. Bill Gates is coming." Enough said lol.
One more thing: If you're lucky, on a cold day, you might catch Elias wearing his sweater vest.