OK, so being a NJ native I have eaten in my share of Italian delis. I really wanted to like this place, but it fell short on what we ordered. I read their online menu after purchasing a Groupon and already made up my mind to order the arrancini and eggplant rollatini -- 2 of my deli favorites.
The rice ball didn't have much flavor and was way too big -- the size of a large softball. Although it was stuffed with the usual tasty fare it just couldn't compete with the amount of rice. The marinara that topped it was quite good.
The rollatini was good, but served barely warm. A dish like this should be served hot and melty. It made me think it might have been laying around a while and nuked. Yikes, I hope not.
My husband ordered a veal parm sub. All of the elements were good -- the bread, cheese, sauce -- except for the veal itself. He said it was just one of those weird Arizona type cuts of meat -- if you know what I mean...
I'm going to give Aiellos Salumeria one more chance and order a deli sandwich and antipasta next time.
The restaurant itself is extremely clean and pleasant.