I'm in love with the ice cream sandwiches here!!! You can build your own or choose from their recommended pairings. After deciding for a long time (they even offered to let me sample the ice creams), I opted to buy two 1/2 ice cream sandwiches:
1) Everything Cookie + Burnt Toffee Ice Cream
2) Ginger Molasses Cookie + Cinnamon Toast Ice Cream
Both were amazing!! The cookies were definitely fresh and baked on the same day as they were soft and chewy The ice cream layered perfectly between the cookies were rich and creamy and tasted homemade with real ingredients. I love how they're generous on the portion size, one 1/2 ice cream sandwich was satisfying enough, eating two was just being greedy lol.
Before I left I even bought another red velvet cupcake to go and ate it when I got home. The cupcake was just OK, a little too dry, so I would only recommend the ice cream sandwiches.
Love: best ice cream sandwiches ever
Hate: ice cream melted too quickly so I had to eat very fast