The Gelato Maker has fantastic Gelato! This is the best gelato I've had since being in Europe last year.
The owner was super nice and allowed my wife and I to sample many flavors before deciding what to get. You have around 20 options to choose from, many fruits and then vanilla, chocolate, reeses cup among others.
My wife and I ended up getting a medium size each with two flavors. She went with pineapple and strawberry and I went with mango and stracciatella. All the flavors were great. The cost was $10.50 total.
I don't think you can go wrong with any of the flavors, but I have a preference for the fruit. Can't wait to head back and go with some other fruit flavors (bloody orange, raspberry, lemon)
The shop is very clean and you can actually see the gelato being made in the back with real fruit.
A definite winner! Once you go here, all other gelato places will be inferior! I wish there was a location closer to Tempe.
Make sure to get a punch card for free gelato after several purchases!