Toby's started off by underwhelming me and then things went downhill. A few friends and I went there for pitchers and breakfast (don't judge me, lol) and my first impression was meh. A standard sports type bar with standard pub fare and breakfast. Before i get into the reasons for the 1 star rating i have to say that our waitress was fantastic. She was friendly and attentive (I guess that's easy when we were the only ones there).
First strike was that they had lost their breakfast menus. Luckily the waitress could remember what they had so that was good. The beer menu was good as well and cheap, no problems on that front. The food was average but reasonably priced, however they muddled details of the order (no big deal, but still not great).
All of the above should generate a 2 or 3 star review but we are coming to the big issue, the cleanliness (or lack thereof) of the men's washroom. There was paper towel all over the floor and one of the urinals was full of puke from the night before, that's really gross. Now I know that cleaning up drunk peoples puke sucks, but you have a bar frequented by college kids, this will happen, you should at least clean it up before opening the next day.