I'm giving a 4/5 mostly due to the fact that the rest of my party absolutely loved this place. I'm still on the fence because I think I got the wrong burger.
To start, we all shared the Gooey Fries. While I absolutely loved how they were loaded with cheese, I'm just not a fan of steak fries. I wonder if they'd let you swap them out for sweet potato fries?
Mr. and Mrs. S shared the Truffle Burger and raved about how flavorful it was. I got the Turkey Burger because the idea of blueberry compote sounded awesome. But it had more sweetness and less tang than I was hoping for. Also, my manchego cheese wasn't melted - disappointing.
However, their crazy shakes were very interesting. Mrs. S got the coffee shake topped with hazelnut pudding and a praline cookie. She said that while the Shake was awesome, the pudding and cookie were very so-so.
Both my husband and myself got the Oreo shake topped with Creme Brûlée pudding and an Oreo. Hubby was 100% in love. I felt the shake was only decent. But that pudding was completely delicious and definitely my favorite part of the meal! I'm not particularly convinced that a shake and pudding really needed to be combined...I found myself eating them separately. But oh well. It was certainly an interesting idea.
Next time we return, I'm thinking I need to try their epic bacon-wrapped BBQ burger. That one could convince me that a 4/5 rating is accurate.