I'm really torn on Cuttlefish because I thought most of the food was actually very good! However, the portion sizes were very small for the price. For my $34 Lemon Prawns and Lobster Ravioli dish, I literally got 3-4 prawns (albeit, large prawns) and 3 ravioli, and that's it. The sides were also very small (and extra $). This is unfortunate because, again, the food was actually pretty tasty. (I'd avoid the crab mac and cheese -- it wasn't that great.) I recommend going on Thursday night when they have a "Date Night" menu and two people can eat for $49. That's a much better value than the money we paid on a Friday night.
The restaurant itself has a great, open décor. I love that they have Vespa scooters at the bar to serve as bar stools. Very cute! Service was also good.