More like a 3.5.
The food is good, but the gyro and cheesesteak my husband and I shared were a bit on the greasy side. Although that is to be somewhat expected with gyro's and cheesesteaks, I feel like they were greasier than gyros and cheesesteaks ought to be. However, I would not recommend their desserts. The service was also good. The reason why I didn't give this place 4 stars is because it didn't really stand out in comparison to other places like the Phoenician (not during the summers), but it was definitely better compared to places like Oliveo.
I think I will need to give this place another try, however. I will update as soon as I do.