I don't understand the great reviews of this place....... Subpar food with a spectacular craft beer list. We had high hopes because McFarland and surrounding has few decent restaurants. We were hoping for a Gates and Brovi like location, or at least a Great Dane, but felt it was more like the food was an afterthought put out to justify calling it a public house.
We had the Reuben which had good bread but was otherwise pre-processed and unimpressive, a salad that was very basic and the Wayfair Parmesan chips, which were surprisingly good. Our daughter had the kids' chicken tenders and fries which were good as well but what you can get at any restaurant. They didn't even have the kids' menu printed so we had to ask and they said they have the usual stuff on a kids menu, no further explanation. The service was slow and obviously our waiter was distracted. The menu overall was unimpressive bar food consisting of sandwiches, burgers and salads, with a huge drink menu.
If you are going for a drink, I highly recommend it, but for dinner steer clear. Madison is chock full of great places to eat, but this isn't one of them. We won't return.