After seeing the "Meatballs coming soon" sign on route 19 for a couple of months my appetite was sufficiently whetted to try this place soon after they opened. So we stopped in here this past week for a late (1:30) lunch. We were seated promptly but never saw a server until I got so impatient I had to get up and go find one. Ok, a startup hiccup I'll overlook for now. The space is quite nice and the bar has about 30 beers on tap plus a root beer which I think is a good touch. And I only saw 2 light beers! Sweet!! Don't waste tap space with light beers!
Once over the server issue, we each ordered the saucy balls - 4 meatballs in a bowl essentially. I chose the classic beef and my dining companion opted for the spicy pork. Both were quite good and flavorful. My pork bolognese sauce was a clear miss though - the nutmeg taste was overwhelming to the point of bringing the whole experience down a notch. Don't order it unless you LOVE nutmeg. I'd prefer it in my pumpkin pie, not my meatballs. The spinach almond pesto sauce sounded really good but is served cold. Still good but would be far better served warm. 4 meatballs is a pretty hefty portion and we left quite full I must say.
I'll give them credit for offering quite a few vegetarian options! After all, this is a "meatball" place and you wouldn't think it's vegetarian friendly but it is.
Overall, I like it here and will return. But you have to want meatballs. Not sure how often I'll fall into that mode but when I do, I know where to get them.