I wasn't sure if I should give them four or five stars, but all things considered I went with the five stars because the pizza is great and the beer selection is spectacular!
First, the pizza: it's typical American style, heavy sauce and cheese pizza. They've got a great selection of unique specialty pizzas that would probably make a Nona roll over in her grave, but I have to say they were quite good. I highly recommend the Mediterranean pizza, even if you're a carnivore. Next time I'd like to try the pulled pork...
The draft beer selection is awesome, they've got a number of beers that I haven't found on tap elsewhere in the Madison area!
If this place had a few more TVs, it could be dangerous--I'd be coming here way more often. Can't wait to come back in the summer and have a seat on the outdoor patio!