Been searching for the best NY pizza for 30 years now, and this place is one of the best ones I found. BUT.. to get the full NY experience, make sure you get a slice that's fresh out of the oven, preferably just cheese (or pepperoni If you long for the grease dripping down your arm).
The other great thing about this place - for those on low-carb or ketogenic diets - they make pizza bowls! No crust, just toppings, sauce & cheese, and a good size portion for leftovers.