I've been here once before and thought it only average. My boyfriend and I tried to go to Shin Bay with a friend a couple of weeks ago but since we didn't have reservations we couldn't get in so we ended up here instead even though I wasn't very enthused about it. It was our lucky night because most of what we ordered was good.
We ordered two rolls, a sashimi plate that came with rice, lobster ceviche and squid salad. I don't recall which rolls we had but I'm sure at least one involved spicy tuna. The squid salads were much larger than we get at most places and pretty average. The lobster ceviche was fresh and had the right amount of acid for me. The waitress asked if there were any fish we disliked but we couldn't think of anything so we ended up with five different fish including mackerel. Neither my boyfriend or our friend liked that so I ended up eating it all. It was OK though I wouldn't go out of my way to order it again. The fish was all fresh that evening so no complaints there.
We also ordered some Nigori sake but unfortunately didn't specify which one so we ended up with a lot more than we needed. The quality wasn't as good as what we typically order. I also had a stock exchange which was refreshing.
My boyfriend and I each ordered some ice cream of different flavors. I had asked the waitress if it was just a small amount as I only wanted a scoop. Turned out to be about three scoops each so it mostly went to waste. It wasn't very good either and I would advise not ordering it.