This place is definitely a hidden gem. If you get a steak for yourself, it's a bit overpriced. But I highly recommend you split a steak with someone for a fraction of the cost, it's definitely worth it considering you get an unlimited baked potato bar and a salad bar (unlimited texas toast as well).
Cooking your steak is not as bad as it seems, as long as you know how to cook (not that hard my friends). I definitely recommend this place if you're in Madison! The service is a coin toss, it can be great but wow, sometimes you get some pretty stupid people but hey, that's life.
In the end, i recommend this place.
ps. this place is NEVER busy. I dont know why, but this place does not get much business.