I live very close to Amico's, so it's been my go-to place for pizza for a while now - especially on Wednesday when their fantastic Italian style pizza is half price - but only recently did I eat-in and try something other than the pizzas and salads.
I was very impressed with the quality (and quantity) of the food. I ordered the pork tenderloin which came in a delicious sweet sauce. The garlic bread that comes with each meal was great, and for my sides I had mixed veg. and scalloped potatoes.
The veggies were great - lightly steamed, nice big chunks and a good variety. The scalloped potatoes... well, I called my mom the next day to tell her that I'd tried real scalloped potatoes for the first time. They were so rich, so cheesy (not like the milky watery things my mom used to make) and overall just fantastic. The entire meal left me feeling very full and very, very satisfied.
The server was great - though I think she may be temporary as the usual girl just had a baby - and the mix of people picking up pizza, eating in and just drinking at the bar made for a great, laid back atmosphere.
There's a reason Amico's has been around over 30 years! Really a fantastic place.