I've been to Bluephies many, many times. What kept me going back was the food - it is pretty damn good. The prices are CRAZY, though - this is a DINER in MADISON not Aix en Provence.
Unfortunately, the service is TERRIBLE!!!
During one visit, the patrons at the table next to us started changing their baby's diaper on the TABLE - the wait staff was unable to intervene - so my husband and I had to say something. Who wants to see a baby's ass during dinner? not to speak of air-borne illnesses landing in our food ~ 3 feet away.