Sometimes places try too hard. Went on a Friday afternoon for lunch, and the place was dead... Willing to cut it slack for that though, as it is June in AZ.
I ordered a burger, my wife the Sgt Pepper melt. We both felt the food was sub par. My burger was burned on the outside, and the meat fell apart. Her melt was like meat loaf on bread. She did like the TX toast type bread that was used. Neither the tater tots nor the sea salt fries were particularly impressive.
Beer selection was ok, but no more impressive than other craft beer bars around. Pretty standard fare as far as that was concerned. The prices were silly high... $10 for a fancy grilled cheese... Really?
The service was ok, as our server was nice. Chairs at the high tables were extremely uncomfortable. Ok to go once, but considering the many options, especially in Old Town Scottsdale, not going again.