To be fair, I might owe Nello's another star, but it's only getting two because of the INTENSE disappointment I had when my wings arrived. I'd always heard that Nello's wings are the best ... turns out they're not. They were soggy. Really soggy. The sauce is about as flavorful as you can find anywhere.
The pizza, as I recall, was okay, but I honestly can't even remember what kind it was, so it obviously didn't make much of an impression on me. Nothing was actually wrong with the food, and nothing would keep me from going back again, but the blurb next to the 2-stars above says it all: "Meh. I've experienced better."