This place is beautiful. The atmosphere is date-worthy and really gets you in the mood to drink tequila. Their drink menu adheres to the atmosphere and offers a variety of tequilas (as real Mexican restaurants do,) as well as micheladas which are easily my favorite drink...ever.
That all being said it was pretty much the only thing I liked about Casa Reyna. My rule of thumb when it comes to most restaurants is : If fish tacos are on the menu order that. If the chef has trouble executing a good fish taco then everything on the menu is likely to be sub-par.
It wasn't the only bad taco though the shrimp, bistek and chorizo were also pretty bad. Literally no flavor what so ever with the fish and shrimp. Both were previously frozen, which is fine, if it wasn't basic Giant Eagle shrimp small and flavorless. Neither were transformed to provide any experience but disappointment. The Bistek and the chorizo were crazy salty.
Sooo this isn't a Mexican restaurant where you go to eat tacos (it sounds crazy I know). The guac was OK too much tomato and not done tableside, despite it being named tableside guac.
The place is too nice to give it a 2-star rating and I haven't had their main dishes which to their defense, looked pretty good and made me wish I didn't order my poop tacos. I had some serious food envy. I will return to try their main dishes, just don't go here for tacos because I'm scared you'll never go back.