A beautiful view of Lake Erie greets the clientele that make their way to Pier W. The view makes up for a slightly disgruntled set of servers ... Decor is stately, and reminiscent of maritime traditions, with deep woods and large glass panes.
Still, the fare wasn't bad (3.5 stars), with the typical surf heavy selection of a place located "on the waterfront". Turf was alright, but not spectacular.
My sense is that Pier W survives based on its location and panorama. If you don't like the lakes, don't come. If you really appreciate a view, dine in the main room, with a date...