This place has definitely taken a nose-dive for the worse.
I haven't been here in nearly two years now and I remember when they first moved to their new location, all the time I've defended the "long wait" (it used to be worth it!) and everything, but I can't anymore.
It's always sad to see a good thing die. I don't understand the 5-star recent reviews at all, but I assume all of you were drunk at the (ingenious marketing plan) bar next door before eating. If you're a regular or come in with a large group, you might get a decent pie. Otherwise, there are numerous local pizzerias left that are still worth the effort. Just try to keep the word amongst yourselves, because Phoenix pizzerias tend to give up on quality or giving-a-damn once they achieve any sort of acclaim. You aren't New York City. You're Central Phoenix. You can't afford all of the eye-rolling unless you produce better than hit-or-miss pizzas after hours of waiting.
If it's any consolidation, though, Bianco's sandwich shop on Central is still rather great.