My husband and I hit up this sweet-fix hotspot every single day and we have yet to be let down. (Granted, Greek-Style Yogurt disappeared for a couple days, but not without major customer backlash and a prompt return to the flavour rotation.)
The team here is beyond fab - we're always greeted so warmly, especially by Demetrie, the owner, who is there EVERY time we're in and has made a conscious effort to learn our names and the name of our dog.
You'll never find a sticky surface, the fruit toppings are consistently fresh and the treats are always stocked.
Try the PB&J... it's off the charts.