Honestly - I don't have much to add that hasn't already been said but I love this airline so much (well as much as you can love an airline!) that I just had to give them my 5 stars! I thought west jet was good - but porter has almost managed to bring 'glamour' back to air travel - or at least make you feel less like herded cattle.
I haven't flown with them to NY yet but their flights to Halifax and Ottawa are great. I completely second the comment about their fantastic in flight magazine, and I love that they have real wine glasses! I really think these guys are onto something! Keep up the great work!