The decor at this place really bothered me. I don't know if this is a regular thing or not, but the lights would dim every 5 minutes or so and we'd end up dining in the dark as the lights slowly came back on. I think it was a consistent thing as the waitresses seemed prepared with flashlights. Personally, I'd prefer to see my food.
I've been here twice. The first time with a group of 6 other people and we all ordered drinks and shared our dishes. We had oysters that time which we greatly enjoyed. I had a mint julep which was delicious and I don't know of many places in Madison that even serve mint juleps. The second time was just me and a friend and I ordered the fried catfish while my friend had the Jambalaya. My catfish was good, nicely battered, well fried so that it was crispy on the outside and really juicy tender fish on the inside. I thought it was a bit pricey for one piece of catfish though. It came with sweet potato fries which were also very good. My friend's Jambalaya came out barely lukewarm. The temperature reminded me of sticking something from the fridge in the microwave just long enough for it to start to warm up but it's nowhere close to serving temperature. A mention to the server and she was quick to reheat it.
The service was fine. The waitress was nice but seemed still new as she wasn't sure how the menu worked, what sides came with with what dish, etc. She had to come and go a couple of times to tell us the specials and find out the answers to our questions. They had a special on some seasonal beers too that they were trying to move out which were only a buck or two.