I've been to the Old Fashioned a bunch of times. The food is good, the beer selection is awesome, and it's a fun, lively place. But my last visit really sealed the deal for me. I ordered a dish at lunch that they only have on the dinner menu. They mistakenly charged me for and gave me the kids' version. When I told the server, they instantly took care of replacing the dish with what I had wanted, and would not allow me to pay the difference between the two. All done with total grace and courtesy.
There are a lot of places with good food, but the Old Fashioned adds in exemplary service. We'll be back. (Even though there are STILL long waits for tables, even after their expansion!)