I've got to say I was impressed. I recently flew to Akron for a family wedding and my cousin took me to Mavis Winkles for my first night's meal.
Atmosphere-wise it was perfect. There's lots of dark wood and Irish gewgaws. Service was friendly, helpful and unhurried. The menu was a combination of "traditional" Irish fare and other dishes with irish-y names. Celtic Calamari and Keiran's Quesadilla? Really? That I thought was a tad much.
However, we decided to order off the more authentic part of the menu. We both started with a cup of potato soup and ordered the beer-battered fish and chips (in honor of our Bostonian grandfather). Everything was great, but HUGE. There was no hope at all of coming close to finishing! One item worth mentioning are the rolls. I was not a fan of the chives mixed in but, that aside, they tasted just like my grandfather's Irish soda bread!
Also, should you attend during this holiday season, consider their drink of the month, mint chocolatini. Pretty good stuff!