Mixed bag on this one. Lovely little place.
Not sure what they are trying to be, exactly. Part of their decor is a small, intimate charm due to the cozy place, their menu suggests they are trying to be eclectic with their variety of pizzas with
an amazing mix of toppings, their crusts are fantastic!
I go there and they ask do you have a reservation? I called the other place mistakenly & said no I did not. I said party of 2 can u squeeze me in? The hostess got snippy w/ me & said 30-45 min wait. Ok I went to car to make a call. Come back 15 min later suddenly some people leave. She begins pushing tables together even my party of two could of been waited on. She had an attitude as she seated me & my son. The waitress came and was very pleasant. Large selection of bottles beers to go w/ the variety of pizzas. After bit my waitress suddenly boxed everything up and presented me with the bill. It was odd. No ... "Can I get you something else? "
Even though there were two large parties surrounding me & people seemed to be enjoying themselves, I got the impression
by my waitresses actions and the hostess who occasionally glanced over at me that I was being hustled out of the restaurant. Ive never felt like that before. I looked around at the 2 large groups ( parties) and all other patrons in the restaurant were couples and thought : They figure that they wont make any money on me & me son and thats why Im being rushed to leave.
So, in conclusion
Good pizza, service was fine but didnt care for the hostess with blond highlighted hair. I guess Id be better treated if I was on a date. Cant say I want to return. I would try the downtown restaurant but not coming back to Sun Prairie cause Im not good enough for them. Just cant figure it out. Tuis is a pizza joint right? Not high society fine dining? Coulda fooled me!