We wanted so much to love this place but it was really pretty so-so. Service was very slow, we had to ask to hear the specials even though we'd heard other wait staff tell nearby diners, my husband's water never got refilled. Our main lunch food was good but took forever. but the biggest disappointment was the pie. Order cherry pie and got a pile of crust and filling that looked like ti had been dug out of the last bit. And worse than that, it tasted blah. The place was full and so hopefully it will fill a niche in DeForest but with so many good places to eat in Madison, I doubt we will travel even that little ways again any time soon. If they can improve the service maybe but the pie was still a disappointment.