I have actually never been in Goodmans but they have a great reputation in the Madison community, so I recommended the place for my boyfriend to go for Christmas. :)
He picked out the most beautiful white gold and garnet earrings and necklace set, just gorgeous. I get compliments all the time.
But mainly, I'm writing this review because a few weeks later, he got a "thank you" card in the mail that had a handwritten message on the inside, something like "Thank you for letting us help you make your holiday special," something like that.
I was so super impressed with that personal touch that I will recommend them to anyone. How many mall stores will do that for you? We will definitely go back - at least he will! :D