If I lived in NYC and had this pizza, I wouldn't return, BUT Pittsburgh's pizza selection is really wildly low. I will visit BF's again because we are in Pittsburgh. I have only been once and here is my review. The crust was correct for a NYC pizza and that is about impossible to find around here. Most Pittsburgh pizzas are undercooked and even if you get a pizza cooked enough the crust is super chewy. Benny's pizza is not super chewy, it is like what you would get in NYC with a nice crunch and a tender center. The sauce was a little light on flavor. It could use a little more cheese. I will return, but like I said, if this was in NYC, I wouldn't. This is the closest place to a NY slice in Pittsburgh. Interestingly, they only have whole pizzas that are huge for $30 or more. I don't mind that too much, but wish they had one other size. I am happy they ONLY serve pizza and have limited selection of toppings. That is what you want because the quality can be high and ingredients fresh. NO wings and other stupid things, thank goodness!