I'm giving this place 4 stars only because of the October dessert, Harvest Spice bread pudding, which you must try!!
Visited here on a Saturday night and it was busy but slowly died down after 7:30ish. Service was terribly slow and the waitress seemed a little "dizzy", I had to keep asking for water even though she kept walking by and could see our entire table had no water. I would go back out of curiosity of what the monthly specials are. Don't bother with the Buffalo chicken soup, it was not good and tasted old.
Good place to go since it was on Man v Food and you can say you've been there.