Cibo seems to suffer from bipolar disorder. We have enjoyed several meals on our own at the bar and with friends at a table or outside for the live jazz. Cibo has all the right stuff but it lacks consistency. One of our visits will be nearly perfect with great customer service, good food and a decent wine selection. The next time we take friends for the first time, the service is lousy, the food is average and the wine doesn't make up for it.
I feel in general it's a cool spot to hang out but for the service and food quality it is overpriced. Some time ago we happened to be there on pasta night. Apparently the chef makes all of the pasta from scratch which is cool but because it is labor intensive, they rarely have it as a special. If you get the chance to enjoy their house-made lasagna...don't delay, it is worth every penny!
Check it out but be prepared to park and walk since parking is scarce and it can get pretty crowded especially on Friday & Saturday nights.