Hi, me again. This time for the pizza, like I said I would. If you walk in and place a full pizza order they'll take 15-20 minutes to make it.
Indeed, they do a better job with pizza than with gelato, but not by a giant leap.
The pizzas they have taste and variety-of-ingredients-wise are better than the Amato's or Pizzaiolo crap, and for that reason would make Gelato Pizza a better option than those chains if you want something a bit more 'gourmet'. Pretty good to enjoy and smells damn fresh, but not quite impressing me enough to make me drool or a regular. The dough on my order was tough to cut and chew on. Quite salty too.
They have a very limited vegan option though. Pricey, though comparable to what Pizzaiolo charges, but at least Gelato Pizza's prices are consistently the same among all their standard menu offerings. And the lone wolf holding down the fort behind the counter on a quiet weekend makes efforts to be friendly.
Verdict on pizza: Meh. Not enough to give Toronto a sense of having an innovative pizza scene.