This place is a great for the money. I think we paid only about $50 a night for a room during Spring Training. From the outside, the place doesn't have much appeal. The neighborhood isn't ghetto but there's nothing decent within walking distance. On the inside, however, it's so charming! The pool/garden/aviary is so cute and retro (but in a way that's been preserved - not left to rot for 30 years). The rooms really blew me away considering the price we paid. They were totally updated and didn't look like what you would expect from a Best Western at all. The extras at this place totally put this little place into the five star category for me. They have free wifi (when most $200 rooms charge) and a business center that let us print for free (note: we were especially thrilled about this because tickets.com has some sort of block on printing tickets that we needed to see our beloved Giants). My only fault that I could find with the place is that they play golden oldies for the people at the pool on the weekends during the day and the speaker was right outside of our door (209). It wasn't obnoxiously loud but it did kind of irritate me.
Overall, we'll most likely stay here again next year to save some money seeing as how everything else in Scottsdale is on the expensive side.
If you're comparing to the Best Western Sundial - I think the Sundial is more expensive and I hear they charge for wifi. The upside to the Sundial (from what I've seen - haven't stayed there) is that it's more centrally located and within walking distance of downtown - as opposed to Papago which is only about a 3 minute drive).