The manager contacted me after this post and offered to remake my meal. I found out they accidentally gave me crab instead of lobster the 1st time...hence the fishy smell. The second time around the steak was well prepared. Lobster was ok, not the best out there and not the worst.
I ate there a 3rd time, and chose to dine in. The food overall was good. Had the Porterhouse topped with crab and asparagus, Parmesan & Truffle Matchstick Fries, Five Onion Soup, Double Chocolate Mousse. The porterhouse was alright, the server asked if we would like it a little blackened...I don't recommend this. It was burnt on the outside and it didn't help the steak. The crab and asparagus topping was very dry and the crab was definitely fishy again. The fries were average, however the five onion soup was one of the best french onion soups I have ever had. Would highly recommend it! The mousse was also really good!
So why 3 stars instead of 4 or 5? Mastro's, Ruth's Chris, etc have a better steak...and overall their side dishes are better. Also, the atmosphere in the other restaurants are more upbeat and nicer decor.