More like a 3.5.
I went for dinner on a beautiful Friday evening in summer with the doors fully open.
Had several dishes: the two notables: the sugo sharing plate (8 hour brisket in home style tomato sauce with good bread to grab it all) was the best one followed by the Alabama tailgators (carpaccio wrapped in crispy bacon).
Service was average, the seating on tall stools not very comfortable, and it was noisier than you'd expect. Not Grand Electric noisy but still.
I liked the food though but nothing spectacular.
Total price for 2 people for food and 2 beers = 95.
Normally a 4 means I'd come back - - but here I wouldn't come back or refer anyone else. But I don't regret going there either.