I loved loved LOVED my experience at the English Rose. A large group of friends and I made reservations of a large (~25 person) group to celebrate an event and they were extremely accommodating to us, especially with how crowded it was. Me and my friend were even a little late, and though we had to stand for our table to open up, she was great about getting us seared with our large party as soon as she could (I believe some other worker had accidentally given our table away).
The tea (caramel peach herbal tea) was the best I've ever had and I am hooked- I had never been to an afternoon tea before and it was all delicious. Finger sandwiches, desserts, and fresh scones with jam and delicious cream.
It's quite a drive from Gilbert but I can't wait to go back!!!