My husband and I tried this place for the first time recently after his dad suggested it over Marios. I have never been to NY but this is how i would picture NY pizza. its huge! you have to fold the slice in order to eat it, which is awesome. I got a spinach calzone and it was really big too and I couldn't finish it. it was still delicious the next day for lunch reheated. The pizza crust is thin, which is great and the sauce and cheese distribution is perfect as well. The atmosphere was what you would expect and fit what I believe they want to capture in a pizza place. You have to seat yourself and you wait till they call your name and as another reviewer noted, yes you must pick up your own trash and throw it away. But that is part of the experience. When in rome right!? We can no longer get pizza anywhere else. Pizza Hut, Papa Johns, Marios, all of them make us cringe and want to gag. this is the best pizza place in town! I do not eat pizza much (too many carbs) but my husband lives for pizza like he needs it to survive and he cannot think of going to another place again.