I finally stopped into Nuthouse during an aimless stroll, and was there for half an hour taking it all in. It's packed with stuff, and it's a lot bigger than it looks! The prices are decent, in my opinion. Great products for fair prices. Not jaw-droppingly inexpensive, but what can you expect for quality (often organic) items?
The reason it went from four star establishment to a five is because of the guy that was working. I was buying some coconut oil, and he glanced it and informed me that they sell it in the bulk section for less than half the price. Without my even asking, he walked to the back and showed me where it was. He also gave me some solid advice on nutritional yeast.
If you live in the area, this place is worth checking out. Great selection, fair prices, friendly staff.