This place is cheap, cute and friendly.
It is a totally typical family-owned-and-operated style campus eatery, but I like the way they prepare their meals. Smart and with a good deal of fantasy.
Just don't expect some chef' marvels or a huge menu there - it is not a restaurant. It is a place where owners share something they like and know how to cook with the rest of us - with student-targeted prices.
Oh yes, the place itself is obviously not a palace - though it's clean, so I can not call it a "rathole". If you have a friend in UoT and would like to meet and chat - Maggie's will be a good choice for that.