I give the pizza 4 stars, but the service was a -2 so the overall rating is just 2 stars. We ordered pizza from here one week ago for the first time and that experience was great! The people on the phone were great and the delivery guy was as friendly as can be and was excited to have new customers. We just moved here from Minnesota and have been trying out local area pizza joints to find the one that could satisfy our taste buds. We were all set tonight to try out 2 more pizzas and were anticipating an enjoyable meal. Pizza arrives and the deliver guy starts out by saying "just for future referene, we don't deliver to baseline" (we are 4.5 miles from their location). We were going to give the guy a $10 tip for a $30 dollar order, but decided to hold back $5. When we opened the boxes only one of the pizzas was what we ordered. I guess the gal on the phone fat-fingered the second pizza and all we got was a cheese pizza. We called to report the error, but the gal on the other end said we got what we ordered, but if we wanted to bring the pizza in they would replace it (WHAT?). Who would do that, we ordered delivery because we did not WANT to drive out to get dinner. This gal also reiterated that they don't deliver to baseline. We told her we got the message and told her we asked that question the first time we ordered a week ago and they told us they did. I guess we will take our business elsewhere. Sorry Jimmy & Joe's, you lost a customer.