My review of My Big Fat Greek Restaurant may be somewhat skewed because I didn't order the Greek items on the menu that others have reviewed. I went with a friend from work and we each ordered a calzone. Really it isn't that difficult to make a good calzone. I ordered the white pizza calzone and while it was descent, there wasn't anything spectacular that stood out. The outer edges were a bit dry, but it improved once I really got into the pie. My friend ordered the Mediterranian calzone and topped it with a side of marinara (to avoid the dryness). I had a bite and it was good.
We ordered a slice of baklava cheesecake for the road. I think the mistake was not eating it there. By the time we made it back to the office and actually ate it later in the afternoon, it wasn't as good as it would have been upon first presentation. Added to that, my friend tried to split it in half and ended up mangling the portion, so the visual appeal was not there.
The atmosphere of the restaurant was nice and the server was very prompt and courteous. I did think that for lunch it was perhaps a little more than a lunch should be. The cheese cake was $5.95 for the slice. The cheesecake, the white pizza calzone and water with lemon was just over $17. With tip I shot my whole $20 on lunch.
I wouldn't mind going back and maybe trying something a little more Greek related. But for a calzone, I would find other alternatives.